Compare mattresses, ranked.

One table. Historical prices, trial periods, warranties, and an explained comparison score — so you can skip the marketing and compare what actually matters.

Comparison shortlist

Ranked by Value Score
Score position 1#01
Nectar
Classic Memory Foam
$699queen · historical
Trial
365 nights
Warranty
Lifetime
Data date
2026-04-19
Value Score
96.3
Brand site
Score position 2#02
DreamCloud
Premier Hybrid
$999queen · historical
Trial
365 nights
Warranty
Lifetime
Data date
2026-04-19
Value Score
93.2
Brand site
Score position 3#03
Nectar
Premier Hybrid
$1,299queen · historical
Trial
365 nights
Warranty
Lifetime
Data date
2026-04-19
Value Score
90.2
Brand site

Full rankings

Tap column to sort
Filter
28 of 28
#Listed features
01
Nectar
Classic Memory Foam
Memory FoamMedium-Firm12
96.3
$699
2026-04-19
365
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.
Brand site
02
DreamCloud
Premier Hybrid
HybridMedium-Firm14
93.2
$999
2026-04-19
365
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support
Brand site
03
Nectar
Premier Hybrid
HybridMedium13
90.2
$1,299
2026-04-19
365
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support
Brand site
04
Saatva
Classic Innerspring
InnerspringMedium-Firm14.5
85.2
$1,795
2026-04-19
365
nights
Lifetime
CoolingEdge supportOrganic+1
Brand site
05
Avocado
Green Mattress
LatexFirm11
85.2
$1,799
2026-04-19
365
nights
25 yrs
CoolingEdge supportOrganic+1
Brand site
06
Saatva
Loom & Leaf Memory Foam
Memory FoamMedium-Firm12
83.2
$1,995
2026-04-19
365
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
07
Bear
Original Foam
Memory FoamMedium-Firm10
73.6
$949
2026-04-19
120
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
08
Avocado
Luxury Plush Organic
LatexMedium13
73.1
$2,999
2026-04-19
365
nights
25 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+2
Brand site
09
Layla
Copper Memory Foam
Memory FoamMedium10
71.1
$1,199
2026-04-19
120
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
10
GhostBed
Classic
Memory FoamMedium-Firm11
70.6
$1,095
2026-04-19
101
nights
20 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
11
Amerisleep
AS3 Memory Foam
Memory FoamMedium12
66.4
$1,499
2026-04-19
100
nights
20 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
12
WinkBed
WinkBed Plus
HybridFirm14.5
64.0
$1,899
2026-04-19
120
nights
Lifetime
CoolingEdge supportMade in USA
Brand site
13
Zinus
Green Tea Memory Foam
Memory FoamMedium10
63.2
$329
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
Motion iso.
Brand site
14
Bear
Elite Hybrid
HybridMedium14
60.1
$2,295
2026-04-19
120
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
15
Puffy
Lux Hybrid
HybridMedium12
59.5
$2,199
2026-04-19
101
nights
Lifetime
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support
Brand site
16
Brooklyn Bedding
Signature Hybrid
HybridMedium11.5
59.1
$899
2026-04-19
120
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
17
Lucid
10-inch Hybrid
HybridMedium-Firm10
57.3
$349
2026-04-19
30
nights
10 yrs
Brand site
18
Tuft & Needle
Original
Memory FoamMedium10
56.5
$995
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
19
Leesa
Original Foam
Memory FoamMedium10
54.5
$1,199
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
Motion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
20
Helix
Midnight Hybrid
HybridMedium12
53.9
$1,249
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
21
Casper
Original Foam
Memory FoamMedium11
53.5
$1,295
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
Motion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
22
Helix
Midnight Luxe
HybridMedium14
52.9
$2,099
2026-04-19
100
nights
15 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
23
Purple
Original Mattress
HybridMedium9.5
51.4
$1,499
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Made in USA
Brand site
24
Leesa
Sapira Chill Hybrid
HybridMedium11
46.4
$1,999
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
25
Purple
RestorePlus Hybrid
HybridMedium-Firm13
41.4
$2,499
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
26
Casper
Snow Hybrid
HybridMedium13
41.4
$2,495
2026-04-19
100
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
27
Tempur-Pedic
TEMPUR-Adapt
Memory FoamMedium11
40.5
$2,499
2026-04-19
90
nights
10 yrs
Motion iso.Edge supportMade in USA
Brand site
28
Tempur-Pedic
TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt
Memory FoamMedium-Soft13
22.4
$4,299
2026-04-19
90
nights
10 yrs
CoolingMotion iso.Edge support+1
Brand site
Advertisement

Questions

Methodology & disclosures
How is the Value Score calculated?
The 0–100 comparison score uses historical queen price (40%), trial length (30%) and warranty length (30%). Lower prices and longer stated terms score higher. It is not a comfort, durability or safety rating. Customer ratings and unverified performance claims do not contribute. See the methodology for the calculation and its limits.
How is this site funded?
Mattress Index is supported by advertising served through Google AdSense — the clearly labeled ad units you may see on the page. Shop links in the table point directly to each brand's own store. Neither advertisers nor brands influence rankings: the Value Score formula is applied identically to every product in the database.
How often is pricing updated?
The current dataset is dated April 19, 2026. It has not been fully revalidated. Dates are shown with product prices; changing the website does not reset a product verification date. Confirm the current model, size, price, availability and return terms with the manufacturer.
Which mattress type should I pick?
Memory foam contours to your body and isolates motion well — good for side sleepers and couples. Hybrids combine coils with foam for better airflow and edge support — good for hot sleepers and heavier bodies. Latex is durable and naturally cooler but usually firmer. Innerspring offers the most bounce and breathability at often lower prices.
Is a longer trial period actually useful?
A trial provides time to assess a mattress at home, but the number of nights is only one condition. Check minimum use requirements, return fees, pickup arrangements and exclusions before buying. A longer trial does not guarantee a better product.

Browse rankings

Advertisement